Posted By Robert H. about 7 months, 3 weeks ago
Top 10 One-on-One Battles,
I’m sure I’m not alone in the opinion that a fight with a good boss can be one of the most enjoyable parts of any game. These encounters are nearly always used and built as tests of the player’s skill, where you really get the chance to show your ability. While there are many types of enjoyable boss fights in gaming, one of my favorite types, if not the best to me, is the one-on-one match. A one-on-one battle against an enemy who is very comparable in strength to the player character carries a thrill and sense of accomplishment that can’t be found in other fights. To honor that kind of boss, I’m going to list the top 10 one-on-one boss battles here. Naturally, some of these entries will give fairly heavy SPOILERS for their respective games, so you were warned.
Important Note: I’m just saying it to be sure people see it. THERE WILL BE SPOILERS AHEAD. YOU WERE WARNED.
(This is just the first part. If you want to see more, they should be in the related videos afterward.)
10.) Protagonist vs. Elizabeth (Shin Megami Tensei: Persona 3)
To start out the list, we have the battle between the main character of Persona 3, known as Minato from the manga of the game, versus the attendant of the Velvet Room, Elizabeth. Despite the fact that Elizabeth helps Minato throughout the game, she doesn’t hold anything back when the challenge is made. She is a bonus boss and requires very good strategy to even come close to winning. She gets to attack two turns to every one of yours, hits very hard, can fully heal herself once, and will instantly kill you if you try to nullify her attacks or bring any other party members. I’ll be the first to admit that this is an ordeal, but it’s hard to think of a time when I felt as much satisfaction as I did when I finally beat her. That feeling and the fact that she takes such careful strategy when many RPG bosses are simply beaten by leveling high enough land her my number 10 spot.
(This is the 2nd part of the fight with the most important parts.)
9.) Lucas vs. The Masked Man (Mother 3)
I hesitate to call this one a “battle” in the traditional sense, because you cannot attack, at least in any significant way. Lucas is unable to hurt The Masked Man much in this fight, as he has finally learned that The Masked Man is actually his long-lost brother, Klaus. Also, The Masked Man will instantly kill your entire party besides Lucas at the start of the fight and will continuously do so if you try to bring them back, basically making it a one-on-one match. The only thing you can do is defend and wait, as most attacks attempted merely make Lucas hesitate at the thought of attacking Klaus. This fight is won through storyline means and, out of all the fights on my list, has some of the heaviest meaning behind it. In the end, The Masked Man begins to hesitate as well and eventually kills himself to stop the fighting. It is truly storytelling through gameplay and, even though I had to defend for quite a while before finally winning, the feelings behind the fight got to me and continue to do the exact same thing every time I battle The Masked Man.
(This is the first part of the battle. The second should be linked in the related videos.)
8.) Player Character vs. Darth Malak (Star Wars: Knights of the Old Republic)
The fight with Darth Malak at the end of Knights of the Old Republic is an enjoyable and complete one. You finally get to the middle of the base where Malak is waiting for you and have the usual pre-fight banter before getting down to the nitty-gritty. Starting the fight, it quickly presents itself that Malak is definitely a tough fighter who hits hard and uses the Force whenever he can, but you can still manage as long as you keep watch on your health. Then, Malak stops to both compliment and insult you before sucking the life out of one of the captive Jedi around the room to refill his own health to full. From there, it’s a dash to somehow destroy all the canisters holding the Jedi before going back to finish Malak, this time fighting without his backup plan. You trade blows back and forth, defeat him, and continue on to the ending, on either the light side or the dark side. It’s a satisfying final fight with enough challenge to be appropriate for a villain who was built up as much as Malak and make it feel like you really accomplished something from Malak’s defeat.
(Skip to about 9:30)
7.) Link vs. Dark Link (Legend of Zelda: Ocarina of Time)
We all know this fight well. From the infamous Water Temple comes an equally infamous boss. Sure, it may be officially called a mini-boss, but Dark Link was tough enough to be considered the most difficult boss in the game. Fought in a fittingly mirage-based room, Dark Link copied your every sword move, but seemed to improve upon each of them. Among other respones, if you tried to do a thrust, he jumped on top of your sword, stood there mocking you for about 2 seconds, then slashed you for good measure. Facing him with the same sword strikes he was equipped with made Dark Link a very difficult foe, although there are some simpler ways of taking care of the boss involving magic abilities or the Megaton Hammer that are still fairly difficult. I didn’t use them in my initial efforts and victory though, due to my lack of knowledge in that department at the time. Due to that, I had quite a difficult time with the guy, even if it was fun. Dark Link would be higher on the list, but there was too much annoyance associated with him compared to the other fights that are ahead of him.
6.) Nathan Drake vs. Zoran Lazarevic (Uncharted 2: Among Thieves)
Most third-person and first-person shooters aren’t known for their bosses. In fact, generally, the bosses in these games tend to be rather lackluster for a variety of reasons. However, the final battle against Zoran Lazarevic is a deviation from that norm, to say the least. It manages to use the third-person gameplay style of Uncharted to make a fun, although tricky fight. Trying to shoot this guy directly will only make you die quickly, and the only way to really do damage is to shoot the explosive sap (it makes sense in context) around the fighting arena as he passes by it. Of course, he is chasing you the entire time with a shotgun and constant cluster grenade tosses, meaning you are constantly on the run, shooting behind you to try and hit the sap when Lazarevic is near it. This is one of the most hectic boss fights I’ve ever been in, with things exploding all around and I loved every moment of the action.

Dark Link really isn’t THAT hard– certainly not the hardest boss in the game, anyway, by any stretch of the imagination.
Even if you don’t resort to cheap tactics like the Megaton Hammer or Din’s Fire, the key to the fight is simply to NOT z-target him. Admittedly, I didn’t figure this out until pretty recently, but z-targeting is basically what allows Dark Link to predict your every move.
Not using it does take some getting used to, but makes the fight a lot more fun and evenly-matched. Still, I would have put it as low on the list as you did simply because he was a mini-boss under Morpha instead of some truly epic clash.
I’m glad you got the most memorable MGS fight in Snake Vs Ocelot in MGS4, but I honestly thought that number 1 was going to be Big Boss Vs The End in Snake Eater. Well I guess it would have been mine anyway. The non cheating way is probably the most intense boss fight I have ever faced, and the PS2 clock trick was one of the craziest boss mechanic I’ve ever seen.
You know, I almost included The End because I love sniping in any video game, so an epic sniper fight like that one gave me so much enjoyment. That’s not even mentioning all the little design touches going into it with the various methods of tracking and how it was basically who could find the other first.
In the end though, I felt that the fight between Old Snake and Liquid Ocelot had such strong meaning and context behind it, in addition to good gameplay design, that it deserved number 1. Still, The End is really, really good. If I wasn’t limiting myself to one per series, it would probably be 2 or 3, easily.
I like how you included the Margaret fight from No More Heroes 2. The song Philistine is also one of my favorites from the soundtrack. Personally though I would have also mentioned the fight with Holly, Alice, Bad Girl, Dr. Peace, Charlie, and Ryuji. Holly, Alice and Dr. Peace because I really did feel for those characters, especially with Holly because even Travis didn’t want to finish her off but she took it upon herself to kill herself. Ryuji is another example of this where him and Travis are equal, which caused them to respect each other a lot. Bad Girl was just really creepy and the fight itself reflects that.
Then there’s Charlie…. and well, I gotta throw in the whacky-ness since the dude is accompanied by his cheerleaders who power up his giant robot. Definitely gives me a Megas XLR vibe and that was awesome XD
Overall there were a lot of great duels in both games… some are whacky and a couple aren’t even a fight (like Letz Shake from the first NMH).
No More Heroes is another one of those series with tons of great boss fights. Limiting myself to one per series made it rather difficult to decide between the bunch, but I didn’t want to have a few games take all the spots.
Of course, all of the ones you mentioned are good. I personally like the fights with Alice, Holly, Bad Girl, Ryuji, Kimmy, and Captain Vladimir the most. Oh, and Sir Henry of course. Still, Margaret wins out for me with the awesome weapons, awesome song, and awesome design.
Though, it’s all good stuff. Thanks for reading.
I understand XD With something like No More Heroes it really is rather difficult to choose just one fight so that way the list doesn’t get bogged down with fights from the same series.
Oh yes, how could I forget Henry… especially with the secret ending in the first NMH.
First thing that came to mind the moment I saw the title of this article: Dante vs Vergil from Devil May Cry 3. How is it not in there? That’s only the best fight in a game full of awesome fights. Rarely do you see a fight like that, where you’re playing an extremely skilled fighter, yet facing a genuine equal. Not a big monster, not a group of enemies – your twin brother, who possesses many of the same abilities you do (Devil Trigger, Force Edge/Rebellion) while also possessing different yet still extremely powerful ones (Yamato, summoned swords). And as is only appropriate for the final boss of such a difficult game, he’s a damn good challenge, even on normal difficulty. You bring your “A” game, or you die.
Ah, I see it’s been suggested below, and they “why it isn’t there” answered. Well, it’s worth repeating, anyway.
On the list, many of them I haven’t played. Even for Persona 3, which I have played numerous times, I’ve never actually fought Elizabeth, since I’ve never done New Game+ (levels of your companions carrying over discourages me from doing so, as that’d trivialize most of the game’s fights). For others… eh, I don’t recall the Darth Malak or Sora vs Riku boss fights being anything special for me. I don’t even remember the Metroid Prime 3 one at all, though I did only play that game once. I’d disagree about including Dark Link – I never found that fight enjoyable at all, just annoying.
For Kingdom Hearts, the one that actually sticks out to me is the fight with Sephiroth in KH2. This strictly from a gameplay perspective, since I haven’t played FF7 (or hadn’t last time I played KH2, and still haven’t played enough of it to have any opinion of Sephiroth as a character, to be more precise), but that fight was very enjoyable, and fairly challenging, especially by that game’s standards. I actually have a save from just before it set aside so I can play it whenever the mood strikes me.
Yeah, I apparently really need to go through DMC 3. Consider that taking a serious jump on my list of games to play.
As for most of the others, it’s clear we just have differing opinions on the ones you have played. I thought Malak was a great finish to the game and one of the better ways to make a boss good with that kind of system. Rundas is my favorite boss from that game by far for various reasons and I honestly think a mirror match like Dark Link works well, even if I agree he was rather annoying.
Kingdom Hearts is a difficult beast to cover in this way, because there are so many good boss fights across the series. I do the exact same thing with a save in front of multiple boss fights across the series so I can play when I feel like it as well. Facing Sephiroth was definitely a good one, but I thought the evenness Riku fought with compared to Sora and the circumstances surrounding the fight really propelled it beyond almost any other. Again though, that’s my opinion.
Thanks for the comment.
Fox McCloud vs Andross from Star Fox 64 needed to be on this list cause not only was Andross was waging war on the Lylat System he’s also responsible for killing Fox’s father James Mcloud.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=BSUW2Rsej7I
Asura vs Yasha from Asura’s Wrath, I don’t even know where to begin.
The Fight: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=0ScKELiepf0
The Story if you have the time: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Zb74QqLfdxw
I was hoping for god hand Gene vs Elvis or devil hand. Those were some pretty good fights.
I agree that Snake vs. Ocelot was probably the best duel. However, that should probably be tempered by the fact that the fight can get really frustrating on Boss hard difficulty. So…many…one punch kills.
I’ll agree that most of these are good choices I’m not so sure about the Elizabeth example. She’s definitely the toughest opponent you’ll face who you can beat without the power of story cut scenes, but I’m not sure I would call it a duel. To me a duel in a story is usually a major battle between two clearly defined characters, almost a clash of ideals, wishes and decisions anthropomorphized.
With Elizabeth it really just seemed a bonus battle against a tough opponent. It’s your list of course but I might have suggested Terra vs. Xehanort in Birth by Sleep or Dante vs. Virgil (the only reason I don’t include Ventus vs. Vanitas is the idiotic quicktime twirl the d-pad trick they pull on you with a machine that really isn’t so good at that).
I understand what you’re saying about Elizabeth, but this is about One-on-One battles, not specifically duels. As ridiculously difficult as it was, I really felt that battle just had a really good overall feel.
Also, I was going with just one entry per series, as a couple series would have probably dominated my list. Considering I find Sora and Riku to be the best one-on-one fight in the series, I couldn’t include Terra vs. Xehanort, even if I really enjoyed that battle as well. Also, that’s the second recommendation I’ve had for Dante vs. Vergil already. I really need to play that game, don’t I?
Glad you enjoyed the list.
Duel Bosses were always the best kind of bosses for me. A well executed duel boss has both you and the boss in even odds, and provides a healthy dose of challenge from beggining to end. Add story meaning to it and cosmetic features such as a memorable arena and a kickass theme, and you have one awesome boss battle ahead of ya.
In any case, while I do agree with most of your pickings (specially for first place. Really, there’s no one more deserving), I’d say I disagree with number six. The fight with Lazarevic was mostly a disappointment for me because, well, it’s the classic “lead the bad guy to a trap/hazard around the arena while not being able to harm him directly, repeat until one of you dies” kind of fight that we’ve seen over and over. If I had to pick a best boss fight from the Uncharted series it would be Talbot at the end of Uncharted 3, which is played in a much more cinematic manner (Thought Sully does butt in at one point, so I guess it doesn’t count).
In its place, I’d pick Dante Vs. Vergil from Devil May Cry 3. What sets it apart from other such confrontations, is that you fight Vergil three times along the game, and in each bout his abilities have evolved somewhat, just like Dante’s. The result is that none of the three battles are exactly the same, and the final fight against Vergil is set up masterfully (and it’s damn challenging too). So yeah.
I agree with you. There are some other individual boss fights that I enjoy more, but in general, a duel boss is my favorite kind.
To be honest, I wasn’t really fond of the Talbot fight, although Sully intervening kind of excluded it anyway. It just didn’t feel like a good finish to the game for me. Lazarevic, I thought, managed to separate itself from most of that type of boss fight through the intensity of it. Still, that’s all just my personal opinion.
Devil May Cry is one of those series I never had the opportunity to play, although it always seemed like the kind of games that would have great bosses, especially someone like Vergil. I’ll take your word for it that it’s good though, and it gives me all the more reason to get around to playing those games.
Regardless, I’m glad you enjoyed the list.