Posted By Robert G. about 1 year, 11 months ago
Note: The following contains spoilers. You have been warned.
The Halo franchise has become a pariah in recent years. Often praised for its excellent multiplayer but lambasted for its poor story, the Halo series is a franchise that you either love or hate. There is little middle ground that a fan can have to bridge the two sides, but one thing that you cannot deny is the impact Halo has made in the gaming world. Love it or hate it, it pioneered a lot of things now commonplace in gaming today.
But today were about to talk about one of the most controversial characters in the Halo universe. Introduced as a deuterogonist in the game Halo 2, the Arbiter was a plot twist that few expected; the players taking control of a member of the Covenant, the religiously zealous alien force at war with Earth. To say the least, the public’s reception on the Arbiter was terribly divided.
A lot of the ire for the character was the sudden change from Master Chief to the Arbiter in the gameplay, which angered a lot of people initially. Another factor was that it changed the perception of the primary antagonists, making the Covenant more sympathetic and the story a more complex tale other than good versus evil. Finally, the Arbiters’ storyline was said to distract players from Master Chief’s and the invasion of earth. To sum it up, reviewer Jarno Kokko succinctly wrote “people disliking the concept of playing on the other side in a game that is supposed to be the ‘Master Chief blows up some alien scum show’ was a plausible complaint.”
But the Arbiter represents more than a fresh perspective against an old enemy, he actually brings in thematic points of the value of truth in religion and redemption, a complete 180 of what Master Chief represents; inner fortitude and valor. Named Thel ‘Vadamee before becoming the Arbiter, he was the commander of the Covenant forces in Halo:Combat Evolved. After failing to defeat Master Chief and losing the Halo ring, a mega structure that doubles as a super weapon that would eradicate all life in the known galaxy. The Covenant, under their leaders the Prophets of Truth, Mercy, and Regret, are attempting to usher in the Great Journey by activating the Halo Rings. The prophets use their power to punish and condemn Thel ‘Vadamee, stripping him of his rank and branding him a heretic for his failures against humanity.

Yea, the Abriter really is one of the best characters in gaming. For everything listed above, but also you get the feeling that he feels really really bad about killing the heretics because you learn that those guys were trying to save the universe. His path to redeem himself after the Halo 1 failure, only to come to the sad realization that everything was a lie and then really redeem himself and save his species and that of the humans is amazing. Especially when compared to Tartarus who has pride at the start because he is a winner and gets to beat up the Arbiter, and then at the end he has Guilty 343 in his hands and hears that the humans are not evil but he is too stupid to realize that it is a lie.
One thing that the Halo storytelling does terribly is tell you what the Prophet of Truth is thinking. The first encounter with the humans has Truth, Regret and ? being low level guys, and they are with those that make first contact with humans, at which point the Forerunner tech that their ship was made up started to react and a Guilty Spark like robot activated and clearly said that humans are the Forerunners. Truth, Regret and ? then realize that their religion is a farce and that humans will make the Prophets lose their power. So the 3 kill the main Prophets and take over the government and demand the extermination of the humans to preserve their power.
But then in Halo 3 they seem to believe straight up that the rings and the Great Journey are real and try to activate the rings. While still hating the humans.
So it was never clear to me if they actually believe in their religion or if they knew it was fake but loved the power.
And, while the Great Schism was crazy awesome, I have no clue what triggered it. I always pretended that the Elites found out that Tartarus killed the Arbiter and lost their shit.
I always liked the Arbiter from Halo 2. I liked the idea of getting to play as someone else other than Master Chief and the idea that one individual and in fact an entire race that once was blindly devoted to false faith sees the truth and instead of hunkering down to defend it no matter what even in the face of weighted evidence and being stubborn, they accept it and move on with their lives, trying to right their wrongs.
That and the Covenant Elites are more interesting to look at to me than Spartans so of course I want to play as one
He may be a character with character, but I can’t help but think that the Arbiter’s character is sort of a an inspiration from Tassadar of the original Starcraft. O_o
Wow, i must have totally missed this when it was posted in the forum.
This was a great analysis, but i have a couple of questions – Where is it stated that The Arbiters name is ‘Thel ‘Vadamee’, and where is it stated that only humans can activate the rings? I don’t recall either being mentioned in any of the games.
Sadly this is part of the problem with Halo and it’s storytelling, it leaves a lot of it out…
Both of these are mentioned in the books and other supplemental media. His name was revealed in the books and is actually on the Halo Nation wikipedia. As for humans being the successors, it was only implied by Guilty Spark and the actions of the Prophets and Brutes (such as Tartarus trying to get Miranda to turn the key) and only stated in the books as well.
For the purposes of this article, it was important to know that because it pretty much sets up the Halo games; the war between the humans was one to eradicate the only evidence from the truth of the Forerunners ancestry, and to find a way to force the Great Journey.
Convoluted at best, frankly.
Thanks. I did have 5 of the Halo novels at 1 point, but i ended up giving them to The Birdman, because i just didn’t have time to read them.
And i must say, the very idea of the humans being descendants of the Forerunners is pretty stupid.